RatePunk Logo
Image of The Marlton Hotel
Image of The Marlton Hotel
Image of The Marlton Hotel
Image of The Marlton Hotel
icon

1/5

Image of The Marlton Hotel
Image of The Marlton HotelImage of The Marlton HotelImage of The Marlton HotelImage of The Marlton Hotel

Safety index

74 out of 100

Show All Photos

Safe area tag

Safe area

Luxury

Pet-friendly

Shopping

The Marlton Hotel

Rating icon

8.7

Good (2,541 ratings)

New York City, United States - 

show on map
Location icon

140 m 5th Avenue

Location icon

700 m New York University

Location icon

2.5 km Madison Square Garden

Hotel Overview

The Marlton Hotel in New York City is a well-reviewed accommodation choice among travelers. Its unique charm, location, and service quality stand out, offering guests a memorable stay. While many find it to be an excellent choice for lodging in the bustling city, there are both positives and negatives to consider based on user feedback.

Thumbs up icon

Hotel highlights

Property

Bar

Service

  1. Prime Location: Situated in the heart of the city, making it convenient to visit major attractions.
  2. Unique Charm: The hotel's historic character is preserved, offering a distinctive, cozy atmosphere.
  3. Attentive Service: Guests frequently compliment the friendly and helpful staff.
  4. Quality Dining Options: The on-site restaurant receives high praise for its culinary offerings.
  5. Comfortable Rooms: Many reviewers highlight the comfort and cleanliness of the accommodations.
Thumbs down icon

Area for improvement

  1. Room Size: Some guests find the rooms to be smaller than expected.
  2. Noise Levels: The central location contributes to potential noise disturbances from the street.
  3. Price Point: Some reviewers feel the hotel is on the pricier side given the room sizes.
  4. Limited Amenities: A few guests mentioned the lack of certain amenities that are commonly found in other hotels.
  5. Reservation Challenges: Occasional complaints about booking and reservation management.

Amenities

Extra beds/cribs

Breakfast included

Pet friendly

Pet friendly

Free WiFi

Free WiFi

Air conditioning

Air conditioning

Restaurant

Bar

Laundry

Laundry

Youtube Icon

Related hotel videos

Score icon8.7

RateScore

Total 2,541 Reviews

Info icon

RateScore is average rating from most popular providers

Blended Web Rating

Icon

7.8

Icon

8.3

Icon

9.0

Icon

4.4/5

Icon

agoda

12 Reviews

7.8 / 10

Icon

booking

882 Reviews

8.3 / 10

Icon

expedia

1,007 Reviews

9.0 / 10

Icon

google

640 Reviews

4.4 / 5

Reviews

Info icon

Words are aggregated from hotel reviews across the web and listed by the most mentions.

Country flagCountry flagCountry flag

640+ People Are Talking

Property

Service

Bar

Dining

Location

Breakfast

Atmosphere

Sleep

Restaurant

Bathroom

Cleanliness

Room

Business

Accessibility

Wi-Fi

Air Conditioning

Safety

Kitchen

Transit

Property was mentioned 225 times

17% Negative72% Positive

Reviews based on Property

User image
Gail Fisher-Lo6 months ago
5/5Google icon

A little gem in the middle of the West Village. Excellent breakfast with a selection from the menu included. Coffee bar in the lobby. Incredible Art Deco building with exquisite detail and about as cozy and welcoming as it gets. AC worked great and lovely bed and bedding. This is the place we will stay from now on when we are in NYC.

User image
Christine Kondra1 year ago
2/5Google icon

Incredibly small rooms - maybe 150 sq feet. Asked for feather free room - did not happen and when everything was replaced they left the feather pillows on the bed behind the foam pillows. The entire hallway and room next door was permeating weed into our room and throughout the entire hallway - when we called downstairs the front desk was unresponsive and the room next door where it was coming from turned on the shower and start spraying air freshener for about 10 minutes. 30 minutes later it started all over again and it was clear they were smoking again. When I pulled back the blanket on the bed, I found a hair that was a bit disturbing as seen in the picture attached. The restaurant, bar and lounge are great - perfect Manhattan/Village scene. it is just upsetting the rest of the experience and that the staff does not seem to care - when i asked for the MOD there was not one at all I was told was in the building. I still have one more night and I am not looking forward to it.

Hotel Quality

Info icon

The quality chart is based on how hotel ratings changed over time.

Mar, 2023May, 2023Now

General Info

Bullet point

Total number of rooms 112

Bullet point

Number of floors 9

WiFi Quality

icon

Download, Mbps

icon

Upload, Mbps

Ping, ms

Idle

12

Download

232

Upload

60

Wifi Speed Is Good For

icon

web browsing

icon

HD online movies

icon

group video calls

icon

online streaming

icon

4K online movies

icon

online gaming

Choose Room

Location Area Map

icon

What's nearby

5th Avenue

140 m

New York University

700 m

Madison Square Garden

2.5 km

Empire State Building

2.5 km

One World Trade Center

3 km

icon

Getting around

New York 9th St. Station

280 m

8 St.

Nearby

icon

Airports Nearby

LaGuardia Airport (LGA)

18 km

icon

Restaurants

Claudette

140 m

Mace

140 m

Stumptown Coffee Roasters

Nearby

99 Cents Fresh Pizza

210 m

Bagel Cafe

280 m

Street View

Icon

Daytime safety

70 out of 100

Safe

Icon

Nighttime safety

48 out of 100

Risky

New York City safety index

Safety

Crime

74

Overall Safety Index

Safe

An average rating of the six safety categories

74 out of 100

Icon

Women safety

Very Safe

Info icon

Likelihood of inappropriate behavior against women.

lowhigh

81

Icon

Physical safety

Very Safe

Info icon

Likelihood of injury due to harmful intent.

lowhigh

87

Icon

Property safety

Very Safe

Info icon

Likelihood of theft.

lowhigh

83

Icon

Political safety

Risky

Info icon

Potential for infringement of political rights or political unrest.

lowhigh

56

Icon

LGBTQ safety

Very Safe

Info icon

Likelihood of harm or discrimination against LGBTQ persons or groups and level of caution required at location.

lowhigh

81

Icon

Medical safety

Risky

Info icon

Likelihood of illness or disease, assessment of water and air quality, and access to reliable medical care.

lowhigh

57

50

Overall Crime index

Moderate

An average rating of the crime categories

50 out of 100

Property crime severity

Moderate

57

Crime category icon

Mugging or robbery  49/100

Crime category icon

Car theft  40/100

Crime category icon

Car break-ins  48/100

Crime category icon

Home break-ins  41/100

Violent crime severity

Moderate

53

Crime category icon

Physical attacks  48/100

Crime category icon

Racism or religion motivated attacks  40/100

Other crime severity

Moderate

54

Crime category icon

Insult or harassment in public  54/100

Crime category icon

Corruption or bribery  53/100

Crime category icon

Drug problem  60/100

Prices Around Property

Average Daily Costs Per Person

icon

Bottle of water 1.5L

$1.2 - $3.3

icon

Coffee

$2.8 - $7.5

icon

Beer 0.5L

$1.6 - $4

icon

Meal, inexpensive restaurant

$14.1 - $37.7

icon

Public transport, one-way ticket

$2.6 - $2.7

icon

Taxi 1km (normal tariff)

$1.5 - $3.5

icon

Meal for 2 people, mid-range restaurant, three-course

$73.6 - $188.6

icon

Bottle of mid-range wine

$10.4 - $28.3

icon

McMeal at McDonalds

$9.4 - $14.1

icon

Coke/Pepsi 0.33L

$1.9 - $4.7

icon

Public transport, monthly pass

$119.8 - $135.3

icon

Gasoline (1 liter)

$0.9 - $1.3

icon

Mobile phone monthly plan

$37.7 - $80.2

icon

Fitness club, monthly fee

$24.5 - $282.9

Weather In New York City

°C
°F

Precipitation In New York City

mm
in

Air Quality

Unhealthy (For Sensitive Groups)

PM2.57

PM1014

53

Slider marker

Limited risk for sensitive individuals. Not recommended to do outdoor activities.

Drinkable Water Quality

water icons

Fair

Water may have some problems, not recommended for daily consumption.

Traffic around property

traffic icons

Moderate

Traffic is moving at a steady pace, smooth driving without significant delays.

House Rules

Clock Icon

Check in after 15:00

Clock Icon

Check out until 12:00

Children welcome

Pets welcome

Our Recent Articles