$431 Cheap Flights from Reykjavik to New York
One-way
Departing from
Reykjavik
Going to
New York, United States
New York (EWR)
United States • September, 2026
98% AI deal score
$1,960 $442
New York (EWR)
United States • September, 2026
98% AI deal score
$1,960 $442
New York (EWR)
United States • February, 2026
93% AI deal score
$1,405 $431
New York (EWR)
United States • January, 2026
93% AI deal score
$1,405 $431
Top Cheap Flight Deals from Reykjavik to New York
Recent round-trip flight deals to New York
Wed, Apr 8 - Sun, Apr 12
Cheapest
Reykjavik (KEF) - New York (JFK)
Icelandair airlines • Direct
New York (JFK) - Reykjavik (KEF)
Icelandair airlines • Direct
$550
$431
-$119
22%
Thu, Jan 29 - Thu, Feb 5
Reykjavik (KEF) - New York (EWR)
Icelandair airlines • Direct
New York (EWR) - Reykjavik (KEF)
Icelandair airlines • Direct
$1,405
$433
-$972
69%
Sat, Jan 24 - Wed, Feb 4
Reykjavik (KEF) - New York (EWR)
Icelandair airlines • Direct
New York (EWR) - Reykjavik (KEF)
Icelandair airlines • Direct
$1,405
$431
-$974
69%
Sat, Jan 24 - Wed, Jan 28
Reykjavik (KEF) - New York (EWR)
Icelandair airlines • Direct
New York (EWR) - Reykjavik (KEF)
Icelandair airlines • Direct
$1,405
$434
-$971
69%
Thu, Jan 22 - Tue, Jan 27
Reykjavik (KEF) - New York (EWR)
Icelandair airlines • Direct
New York (EWR) - Reykjavik (KEF)
Icelandair airlines • Direct
$1,405
$430
-$975
69%
Sat, Jan 24 - Tue, Feb 3
Reykjavik (KEF) - New York (EWR)
Icelandair airlines • Direct
New York (EWR) - Reykjavik (KEF)
Icelandair airlines • Direct
$1,405
$430
-$975
69%
The cheapest time to fly to New York
Ready to jet to New York on a budget? Check out these popular routes with surprisingly cheap fares (one-way prices):
Last-Minute Flights from Reykjavik to New York
Need to get to New York ASAP? Even if you're booking a flight on short notice, there are often last-minute deals available:
Next 2 weeks deals
Last Minute Flight Deals!
In the next two weeks, fly to New York from $675.
⌛ Last-Minute
Reykjavik - NYC
A great last-minute steal for a cross-country flight.
Found 5 days ago
$731
round-trip
Facts About Flights from Reykjavik to New York
To help you plan your journey, here are some quick New York flight facts and tips.
New York city airports
New York is served by a number of public airports, each offering unique benefits to travelers. John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK), located in Queens, is a major international gateway, known for its extensive global connections and numerous terminals. Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR), situated just across the Hudson River in New Jersey, provides another significant hub for both domestic and international flights, serving the New York metropolitan area. LaGuardia Airport (LGA), also in Queens, primarily handles domestic flights and is conveniently located for quick access to Manhattan. For those seeking alternatives and access to the Hudson Valley, New York Stewart International Airport (SWF) offers a more relaxed travel experience with connections to select destinations.
John F. Kennedy International (JFK)
New York, United States
Newark Liberty International (EWR)
New York, United States
LaGuardia (LGA)
New York, United States
New York Stewart International Airport (SWF)
New York, United States
Pro tip: search “New York (Any)” to see fares to all New York airports – sometimes one is cheaper than the others on your dates.
Insights for flights to New York
Cheapest airport
Newark (EWR)
While not *technically* in New York City, Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR) is a major gateway to the New York Metropolitan Area! Just a hop, skip, and a jump across the Hudson River, EWR offers a plethora of domestic and international flights, often at prices that make your wallet sing. Plus, with easy access to both New York City and New Jersey, you get the best of both worlds!
Nonstop vs. 1-stop
100+ cities
New York, a major hub, provides a whirlwind of options, connecting you to over 100 cities with popular routes to London, Los Angeles, and Miami!
EWR Airport Deal Stats
Current most discounted routes
Avg. most discounted routes (last 3 months)
EWR airport insights
Best days to catch a deal
Mon, Wed
Based on the data, Monday has the highest count of cheapest deals for Newark Liberty International Airport. Therefore, you're most likely to find a deal on Monday, followed by Wednesday.
Avg. deal survival time
15.5 hours
Deals from Newark Liberty International airport typically survive for about 15.5 hours. This means you should book quickly when you find a deal you like!
Rare deal frequency
11 deals
We found 11 rare deals for flights departing from Newark Liberty International Airport in the past month, all with an AI Deal Score of 90 or higher. These rare deals are typically mistake fares, special promotions, or ultra-discounts.
Average price drop
-77%
The average price drop for flights to Newark Liberty International Airport is 76.9%, meaning you could save a significant amount on your trip. Keep an eye on flight prices to Newark and book when you see a deal to take advantage of these potential savings.
Next 4 weeks: deal forecast
Newark Airport Flight Forecast (Next Month)
Based on current trends, flights from Newark Liberty International Airport are expected to remain relatively stable next month. There are no significant price drops or increases anticipated in the near future.
Top 5 biggest price drops (last 3 months)
Found on December 19
Atlantic City - EWR
$615 → $71
88%
Found on December 21
Oujda - EWR
$6,000 → $691
88%
Found on December 24
Ponce - EWR
$650 → $101
84%
Found on December 20
Douglas - EWR
$2,150 → $388
82%
Found on December 23
Trujillo - EWR
$1,185 → $210
82%
Check these nearby airports too
Looking for more options? These airports near EWR sometimes drop rare deals too:
Long Island MacArthur (ISP)
~5 rare deals/month
John F. Kennedy International (JFK)
~14 rare deals/month
LaGuardia (LGA)
~3 rare deals/month
If you’re flexible with departure cities, it’s worth keeping an eye on nearby airports — especially ISP and JFK for long-haul deal surprises.
When Is the Best Time to Fly from Reykjavik to New York
Timing is everything when hunting for cheap flights. Here are data-backed insights on the best times to fly to New York:
Cheapest month
January
Cheapest month
January is often the cheapest month to fly to the Big Apple! You'll find fewer tourists braving the cold, meaning lower prices and shorter lines. Plus, imagine cozying up in a charming café after a snowy stroll through Central Park – pure magic!
Best day to book
Tuesday
Best day to book
Tuesday tends to be the golden day to snag flight deals to New York City. Airlines often release new fares early in the week, and by Tuesday, the competition is on! Keep an eye out for those mid-week bargains to save some serious dough.
Cheapest days to fly
Wednesday
Cheapest days to fly
Flying mid-week, especially on a Wednesday, can save you a bundle when heading to New York City. Most people prefer traveling on weekends, so airlines drop prices to entice travelers during the week. You'll not only save money but also experience slightly less crowded airports – win-win!
Advance booking sweet spot
2 months
Advance booking sweet spot
Snagging flights about two months in advance is often the sweet spot for deals to New York City. This timeframe balances planning ahead with avoiding last-minute price surges. Start your search early, set up fare alerts, and watch those savings roll in!
New York Airports & Ground Transportation
One big question for travelers is which New York airport to fly into. Here’s a quick guide to New York’s airports and how to get to the city from each:
John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK)
Welcome to the Big Apple! JFK is one of the busiest airports in the world and the primary international gateway into North America. After landing, you'll find a wide array of shops, restaurants, and lounges to relax in. Getting into Manhattan is a breeze with options like the AirTrain connecting to the subway, taxis, and ride-sharing services. For a smoother trip, consider booking your transportation in advance, especially during peak hours. Plus, keep an eye out for the iconic TWA Hotel, a retro-chic hotel inside the old TWA terminal!
Tip: Allow extra time for navigating this large airport, especially if you have connecting flights.
Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR)
Touching down in New Jersey, Newark Liberty International Airport offers a convenient alternative to JFK, serving the New York metropolitan area. The airport boasts three terminals with a variety of dining and shopping options. From Newark, you can hop on the NJ Transit train directly to Penn Station in Midtown Manhattan, making it a great option for reaching the city center. Taxis, ride-sharing, and airport shuttles are also readily available. EWR is often less crowded than JFK, providing a potentially smoother travel experience.
What to Do in New York
New York isn’t just about getting there – it’s about enjoying the country once you arrive! Here are some top things to do in New York, organized by interest:
Sightseeing & landmarks
New York City is full of iconic landmarks like the Empire State Building and the Statue of Liberty, offering breathtaking views and a sense of history. Don't forget to stroll through Central Park, a green oasis in the middle of the urban landscape, perfect for a relaxing day out.
Arts & culture
From Broadway shows to world-class museums like the Metropolitan Museum of Art and the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA), New York City is a cultural hub. Explore diverse neighborhoods like Greenwich Village and Harlem for unique artistic experiences and live music venues.
Food & nightlife
Indulge in New York's diverse culinary scene, from street food to Michelin-starred restaurants, offering flavors from around the globe. Experience the vibrant nightlife with rooftop bars, jazz clubs, and trendy lounges that keep the city buzzing until the early hours.
Shopping & fashion
Shop 'til you drop on Fifth Avenue, home to luxury boutiques and flagship stores, or explore trendy neighborhoods like SoHo and Nolita for unique fashion finds. Don't miss out on the vintage shops and sample sales for one-of-a-kind pieces that will elevate your style.
Nearby getaways
Escape the city for a day trip to the beautiful beaches of Long Island, or explore the scenic Hudson Valley with charming towns and wineries. For a nature retreat, head to the Catskill Mountains for hiking, skiing, and breathtaking views.
Events in New York This Month
new york comedy club (east village)
Enjoy live comedy on Monday, December 1st, with a lineup of talented comedians.
relish | ages 36-48| new york’s elevated speed dating
Experience a sophisticated speed-dating night in New York City, offering a relaxed atmosphere for meeting singles without the typical bar scene or awkward setups. Meet 8-12 singles in one engaging evening.
33rd african diaspora international film festival
The 33rd Annual African Diaspora International Film Festival (ADIFF NYC 2025) returns to New York City from November 28 to December 14, 2025, marking 33 years of celebrating and showcasing diverse stories from across the African diaspora through film.
open mic event
Enjoy the musical talents of Karen Maynard on vocals, Michael Howell on guitar, Motoki Mihara on bass, and John Cooksey on drums, as they perform a variety of jazz and contemporary pieces.
New York Weather
Weather in New York
Wed, Dec 24
5%
7° 0°
5%
Thu, Dec 25
Frequently Asked Questions About Flights to New York
Pro Tips for Finding Cheap Flights to New York
Finally, to wrap up, here’s a cheat sheet of pro tips that experienced travelers use to save on New York flights:
Be Flexible With Your Dates: Flying mid-week or during the off-season can unlock significant savings. Airlines often lower prices to fill seats on less popular travel days, so shift your schedule if you can!
Consider Nearby Airports: New York has several airports (JFK, LGA, EWR). Check fares to all of them! Sometimes flying into a slightly further airport can save you a bundle, and who doesn't love saving money?
